Taming (and Reframing) your Inner Critic
How to Tame Your Inner Critic: Best Practices for Strategic Leadership
We all have that voice in our heads—the one that questions our choices, criticises our mistakes, and sometimes makes us feel like we’re not good enough. Whether you recognise it as "the inner critic" or as the voice of self-doubt, it’s an almost universal experience. But how we respond to that voice can make all the difference in our leadership effectiveness, personal growth, and overall well-being.
In this blog post, based on a recent podcast conversation, we’ll explore best practices for taming the inner critic so it helps us become better leaders—rather than hindering our progress. Here’s how you can transform that voice from a saboteur into a tool for growth.
1. Recognise the Inner Critic’s Purpose
The first step in taming your inner critic is to understand its role. The inner critic is often rooted in our past experiences, developed as a mechanism for self-protection. It may have served a valuable role when we lacked certain skills or when we faced a more hostile or critical environment. However, as we grow and develop, the critic often lags behind, continuing to feed us outdated messages about our worth or abilities.
Best Practice: Acknowledge that your inner critic was once helpful but might not be relevant to your current circumstances. Compassionately thank it for its past role, but let it know it’s no longer needed to keep you safe in the same way.
2. Apply Discernment: Choose Which Voices to Listen To
When the inner critic speaks up, it’s easy to believe its judgments are true. But the critic’s voice is just one perspective among many. In moments of stress or failure, we can be quick to buy into the negative thoughts it presents. The key is learning to pause, take a step back, and apply discernment.
Best Practice: Take a moment of reflection. Is this voice helping you grow, or is it keeping you stuck in a cycle of self-doubt? You can choose which perspectives to absorb. Instead of accepting the critic’s voice as fact, balance it with other viewpoints, such as compassion, curiosity, or even hard evidence.
3. Shift Into Neutral: Pause and Breathe
One of the most effective tools for dealing with the inner critic is the ability to pause. In the heat of the moment, when that voice is loudest, we often respond reactively, either by shutting down, getting defensive, or spiraling into self-blame. To avoid these automatic reactions, it’s crucial to take a beat.
Best Practice: When you catch yourself in the grip of your inner critic, take a deep breath. Physically reset your body and mind. A few deep breaths can shift you from a reactive, emotional state to a more strategic, calm, and thoughtful one. This pause gives you the space to decide how you want to respond rather than simply reacting.
4. Invite Other Perspectives: The “Inner Boardroom” Approach
The inner critic tends to dominate the conversation, often ignoring other perspectives. To counter this, try visualising a "boardroom" of different voices and perspectives—one where the critic is just one member of the team. This practice is about giving other voices—supportive friends, mentors, and even your future self—a seat at the table. By inviting a variety of viewpoints, you can create a more balanced, objective perspective.
Best Practice: Visualise your inner boardroom and ask yourself: What would a supportive colleague say in this moment? What advice would my mentor give me? What would my inner sage, the wiser version of me, say about this situation? By including these voices, you create space for self-compassion, growth, and more effective decision-making.
5. Cultivate Compassion: Speak to Yourself Like a Friend
Think about how you would respond if a friend came to you with the same concerns you’re currently grappling with. Would you berate them or remind them of their strengths? Would you focus on their flaws or help them learn from the situation? Our inner critic can be harsh, but the inner guidance we offer to others is often kinder and more compassionate.
Best Practice: Treat yourself with the same care and empathy you would offer a friend. When the inner critic speaks, pause and ask yourself, What would I say to a colleague or friend in this situation? Practicing this self-compassion can help you create a supportive internal dialogue that fosters learning, growth, and resilience.
6. Focus on Solutions, Not Just Problems
The inner critic often focuses on what went wrong or what we could have done differently, without offering any real solutions. This can paralyse us, keeping us stuck in a loop of self-criticism. In contrast, inner guidance looks forward, encouraging us to consider how we can improve, learn, and grow from the experience.
Best Practice: Shift your focus from "What did I do wrong?" to "What can I learn from this?" and "What steps can I take to move forward?" This mindset helps you view mistakes as opportunities to improve, rather than as evidence of failure.
7. Create Space for the Inner Sage
The inner sage is a voice of wisdom and perspective that often gets drowned out by the inner critic. This voice doesn’t judge or berate; instead, it offers guidance, compassion, and actionable insights. The sage can be a future version of yourself—looking back on the situation with a broader, wiser perspective—or it can be a mentor or trusted colleague.
Best Practice: Tap into your inner sage by asking yourself, What would my wiser, future self say about this situation? Visualising yourself five or ten years from now, looking back at the mistake or challenge, can give you the clarity and perspective you need to move forward with confidence.
8. Use a Simple Methodology: Notice, Shift, and Sage
A simple but effective way to manage the inner critic is to follow a three-step process: Notice, Shift, Sage.
Notice: Recognise when your inner critic is at work. Simply identifying it is a powerful first step.
Shift: Take a deep breath and physically or mentally shift out of the emotional reaction. This neutral pause creates space for a more intentional response.
Sage: Ask yourself, What would my inner sage say? or What is the solution or learning in this situation? This step helps reframe the criticism into something more productive and forward-looking.
Best Practice: Make this three-step process a habit. By noticing, shifting, and seeking guidance from your inner sage, you train yourself to manage your inner critic effectively and respond with intention.
Conclusion: Turning the Inner Critic into a Strategic Ally
The inner critic doesn’t have to be the enemy. With compassion, discernment, and a strategic approach, you can transform it from a voice of limitation into a tool for growth. By shifting your perspective and inviting other voices into the conversation, you’ll be better equipped to handle challenges, learn from mistakes, and ultimately become a more effective, strategic leader.
Remember, it’s not about silencing the inner critic, but about choosing when and how to listen to it. By practicing these best practices, you can turn that critical voice into a guide that helps you grow, learn, and evolve as a leader.
Need more leadership tips? Subscribe to our newsletter for more insights and strategies, or listen to our latest podcast episode to dive deeper into the art of strategic leadership!